Chris Leggat via Unsplash

My clients and I are very disappointed but not surprised by the Historic Preservation Commission’s decision on Thursday night denying the demolition of 109 Union St. We presented unrebutted testimony from the asbestos expert who had been working on the remediation for three years. After hundreds of thousands of dollars, the property remains asbestos-ridden and the only safe and economically feasible solution is demolition.

The last hearing noted that my client’s application hadn’t included a structural engineer to opine on the possibility of preserving the facade. We presented a structural engineer, also unrebutted, who clearly at length opined that while anything is possible given unlimited funds, in this instance, there is no safe and economically feasible way to preserve this structure given the asbestos condition and the nature of the old and uniquely framed construction.

My clients and their family loved the house but have been trapped in a three-year tragic ordeal through no fault of their own. The town’s historic consultant seems to think they are responsible for their contractor’s negligence that set this ball rolling, as if they wanted to be caught between this rock and the Historic Preservation Commission hard place. Curiously, three members clearly understood how devastating this has been and how asbestos-ridden and unsafe this house is. The other three demonstrated a lack of empathy or basic understanding of the situation and seemed to grope for rationale’s to deny my clients and prolong their ordeal. They rested on “good-faith efforts to sell the property.” That clause in the ordinance presumes a normal or somewhat rundown structure, not a toxic waste zone, and just how protracted and how financially devastated do they have to be to provide a habitable structure for their family?

The house has now been vacant for three years. I’m at a loss to understand how an uninhabitable, asbestos-ridden structure benefits the owners, the neighborhood or Montclair. It’s not going to improve with age.

Rich McMahon

Attorney, Montclair

SAVE MONTCLAIR LOCAL: We need your support, and we need it today. The journalism you value from Montclair Local, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, depends on the community's support — we exist because the old model of selling ads alone just can't fund journalism at the level we endeavor to provide. That's why you've seen other local newsrooms cut back staff or shut down entirely. Montclair Local was created because we believe that's unacceptable; the community's at its best when triumphs are celebrated, when power is held to account, when diverse lived experiences are shared — when the community is well-informed.

Montclair is seeking to raise $230,000 from donors, members and grantors between Oct. 1 and Dec. 31 to put us on firm footing for 2022, and continue supporting the hard work of our journalists into the new year and beyond. Visit to see how we're doing and make your contribution.

Montclair Local’s Opinion section is an open forum for civil discussion in which we invite readers to discuss town matters, articles published in Montclair, or previously published letters. Views expressed and published in this section are solely those of the writers, and do not represent the views of Montclair Local.

Letters to the editor: To submit a letter to the editor, email, or mail “Letters to the Editor,” 309 Orange Road, Montclair, NJ, 07042 (email is preferred). Submissions must include the name, address and phone number of the writer for verification. Only the writer’s name and town of residence will be published. Montclair Local does not publish anonymous opinion pieces.

Letters must be no more than 500 words in length, and must be received by 5 p.m. Monday to be eligible for potential publication in that week’s Thursday print issue. Letters may be edited by Montclair Local for grammar and style. While our goal is to publish most letters we receive, Montclair Local reserves the right to decline publication of a letter for any reason, including but not limited to concerns about unproven or defamatory statements, inappropriate language, topic matter far afield of the particular interests of Montclair residents, or available space.

Town Square: Montclair Local also accepts longer-form opinion essays from residents aiming to generate discussion on topics specific to the community, under our “Town Square” banner. “Town Square” essays should be no more than 750 words in length, and topics should be submitted to at least seven days prior to publication.